While our initial intrigue centered around the use of the term “Irish Bourbon” – a term that cannot exist according to U.S. booze labeling laws – our staff was completely caught off guard by the quality behind that label. While these bottles have become instant collector’s items since the TTB finally woke up and realized their mistake (the label has since been terminated), we managed to snag the initial shipment to California before the bottles were sent back. A marriage of 10 year old Irish whiskey with American LDI-distilled Bourbon, we think the John L. Sullivan has created much more than a simple novelty. They’ve created an entirely new genre of whiskey – one we’re very interested in seeing more from. Check out the glowing reviews from our staff, but don’t sleep on this deal. The idea of “Irish Bourbon” won’t exist beyond this initial batch.

John L. Sullivan “Irish Bourbon” Whiskey (750ml) ($32.99)
IMPORTANT: Do not mistake this quirky little whiskey as a gimmicky or one-off collectable. While attempting to introduce something new to the market, the folks behind John L. Sullivan whiskey might have just struck gold. When you taste the Sullivan “Irish Bourbon” (a name that has already been banned by the U.S. Federal Government, so don’t expect to see this label for much longer), you’ll understand exactly what we mean. Imagine all the smooth, easy-drinking, and sweet-barley character of your favorite Jameson bottle, but add in the rich oak flavor of your favorite Bourbon on the finish. Whoever blended these two components together did so with an absolutely masterful touch. The creamy texture of 10 year old Irish goodness (aged in sherry, no less) melds harmoniously and seamlessly with the bold American whiskey character. Rather than losing their identities in the process, these two whiskies elevate one another and improve their finest aspects. In fact, this whiskey is so good you might find yourself adding a bit of Redbreast to your next glass of Buffalo Trace, or vice versa. Beware of buying this bottle, however: it won’t last the week once you open it. This whiskey is simply too delicious and too drinkable to sip slowly.

Ryan Woodhouse | K&L Staff Member | Review Date: February 19, 2016
I was confused by the name at first…”Irish Bourbon…?” But it’s exactly what is says on the tin (or bottle)…a marriage of Irish Whiskey and Bourbon. “But why?” I hear you say…why create such a mutt? Well because it combines the drinkability of Irish Whiskey with the richer textures and flavors of Bourbon! It’s built from up to ten year old base spirits so not only is it deliciously drinkable but at this price point it’s a steal as well. There’s nothing contrived about this bottling, it’s not trying too hard to be cool…it just wants to be drunk and enjoyed plain and simple…

David Othenin-Girard | K&L Staff Member | Review Date: February 19, 2016
This is just supremely drinkable whiskey, plain and simple. It’s everything you love about Irish whiskey with an extra kick. A no-brainer.

David Driscoll | K&L Staff Member | Review Date: February 19, 2016
Just like I have no desire to eat at the French Laundry every single night of the week, I have no desire to drink Macallan 30 or Pappy Van Winkle after work on a Wednesday. I like coming home to a beer and a shot at 7:30 PM most days and this bottle of Sullivan “Irish Bourbon” just became my new go-to. They pretty much did the impossible here. They improved what was already a classic style of whiskey. I may start combining all my Midleton Rare into my Wild Turkey editions from now on. I’m hooked.

Gary Westby | K&L Staff Member | Review Date: February 18, 2016
This unusual blend of Irish & Bourbon Whiskey surprised me with its round, easygoing, and completely delicious drink-ability. This isn’t just for the whiskey guy that has to try everything, this great tasting easy going drinking for anyone who loves brown water. The clean, refreshing, light Irish side of this bottle is the perfect match for the sweet oak and extroverted corn sweetness of its Bourbon side. Yum!
 
K&L Wine Merchants
http://www.klwines.com
Phone: 877-KLWines (toll free 877-559-4637)
Email: wine@klwines.com
San Francisco, Redwood City, Hollywood CA

“